Dove's
comment on radio-controlled shock collars!
I feel
electronic training
devices are overused and are nothing but a quick-fix solution. While
they
give a "correction" (a zap) to deter the dog from doing something and
eventually
the dog learns not to do that behavior, it is purely negative
reinforcement
training.
Where is
the positive reinforcement
when the dog is behaving? It is far more humane, effective and usually
faster, to actually train your dog using a one-on-one human-dog
interaction
with lots of positive reinforcement for the correct behavior and
nothing
but a disapproving tone of voice to correct a bad behavior.
When
someone puts an anti-barking
collar on a dog and then goes off to work, when does the dog get
praised
for being quiet? How are they to effectively learn not to bark when
there
is no one there asking them to be quiet and then praising them when
they
are quiet?
These
electronic devices
also take away from a dog's confidence. After every negative
correction,
it should be immediately followed with a positive reinforcement on what
the right behavior is. Yet all they get is negative, negative, and more
negative with these collars.
|